Meredith Gaudreau still haunted by Johnny & Matthew's fatal night.

On August 29, 2024, Johnny Gaudreau, the 31‑year‑old NHL forward for the Anaheim Ducks, and his younger brother Matthew were killed in a fatal biking accident on a quiet suburban road in New Jersey. The siblings were struck by a vehicle driven by Sean M.

Higgins, who later admitted to having consumed alcohol before the collision. Meredith Gaudreau, 34, says the shock still feels like yesterday.

She told an interview that the night she learned of the deaths keeps replaying in her mind, describing it as a haunting: “Sometimes I find myself kinda just zoning out….” Meredith added that she thinks about the moment 24/7 and remembers better times when she sees their children.

## Background & Context

The crash occurred on Route 27 near a small park where the brothers had set up their bicycles for a Sunday ride. The area, known for its low traffic volume, is a favorite spot for local cyclists.

Police reports indicate that the vehicle was traveling at an estimated 55 mph—well over the posted limit—and that the driver’s blood alcohol concentration was above the legal threshold.

Witnesses described the sudden impact as “a flash of white and metal,” and emergency responders arrived within minutes, but both brothers were pronounced dead at the scene.

Johnny and Matthew had shared a passion for cycling since childhood, often racing through the streets of Denver after school. Their partnership extended beyond sport: they co‑owned a small bike repair shop during the off‑season, helping friends in their community keep their rides in top shape.

On the day of the accident, they had planned a leisurely ride to clear their minds before an upcoming family celebration.

Meredith and Johnny were expecting their third child at the time of the tragedy. Their wedding in September 2021, attended by close friends and family, was a joyous occasion that set the tone for a future filled with love and laughter.

The birth of daughter Noa in September 2022, son Johnny Jr. in February 2024, and son Carter in April 2025 were milestones that grounded the family amid the demands of a professional sports career.

## History

Johnny Gaudreau’s journey to the NHL was marked by perseverance and talent. Drafted 48th overall by Anaheim in 2013, he broke through during the 2016‑17 season, earning a spot on the NHL All‑Star team and ranking among the league’s top scorers.

Known for his agility, play‑making ability, and quiet leadership, Johnny became a fan favorite in Anaheim and a respected teammate across the league. His off‑ice personality—humble, generous, and fiercely protective of his family—made him a role model for young players.

Matthew, though not yet a professional athlete, had carved out his own path as a high school soccer coach in Colorado. He was known for his dedication to mentorship and community service. The brothers’ shared dedication to sports and community involvement underscored the tragedy’s impact on fans and friends alike.

## Fan Reaction

Within hours of the news, fans poured out their grief across social media, sharing photos of Johnny’s iconic moments on the ice and tributes from fellow players. Former teammates from Anaheim, including captain Trevor van Riemsdyk and winger T.J.

Oshie, posted heartfelt messages acknowledging Johnny’s “unbelievable talent” and “deep compassion.” The Ducks organization released a statement honoring Johnny’s legacy, announcing a memorial game to be held in his name during the upcoming season.

The broader hockey community also organized a nationwide tribute night, with jerseys displayed at arenas across North America. Fans draped scarves bearing Johnny’s number 33 on the sidelines, and many players signed autographs for his children in an attempt to connect their love of the sport with their personal loss.

## Industry Impact

The incident sparked a conversation about road safety for cyclists and the dangers of impaired driving—issues that had been growing concerns for sports organizations.

The NHL’s Players’ Association launched a campaign titled “Safe Roads for All” in partnership with local law enforcement, aiming to raise awareness about safe cycling practices and the consequences of alcohol‑related driving.

Anaheim Ducks head coach Craig Patrick emphasized that the league would invest in additional community outreach programs to support families of players, recognizing the fragility of life beyond the rink.

The accident also prompted a review of bike safety protocols in New Jersey, leading to increased funding for bike lanes and educational programs in suburban communities. The state legislature considered new legislation mandating stricter penalties for drunk driving, .

## Legal Proceedings & Future

In December 2024, Higgins was indicted on multiple charges: two counts of first‑degree aggravated manslaughter, two counts of second‑degree reckless vehicular homicide, a fourth‑degree tampering with physical evidence charge, and a second‑degree leaving the scene of a fatal accident. Higgins pleaded not guilty to all charges.

A pre‑trial conference is scheduled for September 16 to determine whether he will face bail or a preliminary hearing. While the case remains pending, family members have expressed their hope that justice will be served swiftly.

Meredith has chosen to keep the focus on honoring her husband’s memory rather than publicizing legal details. “We want the world to remember Johnny for who he was, not the circumstances of his passing,” she says, underscoring her commitment to preserving his legacy.

## Honoring Johnny Gaudreau’s Legacy

Meredith keeps Johnny’s memory alive by preserving his belongings in their home. His jacket hangs in the living room, while his polished shoes line a shelf beside a framed photograph of him blowing out a birthday candle.

She shares stories about Johnny’s favorite spots—such as the old pier in Lake Tahoe where he once skated on a makeshift rink—and recounts moments of triumph and laughter.

The family hosts an annual memorial dinner each September, inviting friends, teammates, and community members to share memories and celebrate Johnny’s impact. During the event, a video montage of his career highlights plays on the screen, followed by a moment of silence for the brothers.

Meredith’s children are encouraged to share their own stories, ensuring that Johnny’s legacy continues to grow with each new generation.

The Ducks organization has honored Johnny by installing a commemorative plaque in the locker room, where he often practiced his shots before games. The plaque includes a quote from Johnny: “It’s not about the destination; it’s about who you become along the way.” This sentiment reflects the values Meredith and her family hold dear.

## Impact on the Gaudreau Family

The loss has profoundly shaped the family’s trajectory. While they continue to anticipate a third child, Meredith emphasizes that motherhood provides a source of solace and purpose. “Seeing my babies smile reminds me that life goes on,” she shares, describing how those moments help her process grief.

Meredith and her sister-in-law Madeline coordinate regular family gatherings, reinforcing a support network that has proven essential during the grieving process. Their parents also travel frequently to visit the children, ensuring that Johnny’s presence remains embedded in daily routines.

The community has responded with generosity: charitable donations have flooded in, many directed to causes that Johnny championed—such as youth sports scholarships and bike‑safety outreach.

The Gaudreau family has pledged to match a portion of these donations, extending the reach of Johnny’s passion for helping young athletes find safe ways to pursue their interests.

## Conclusion

Meredith Gaudreau’s devotion to preserving Johnny’s legacy underscores a family’s resilience amid tragedy. Her continued presence in the lives of her children and community, combined with the broader industry’s response, keeps Johnny’s spirit alive.

While the pain of that August night lingers, the ripple effects of his life—on fans, teammates, and countless young athletes—continue to shape a brighter, safer future for all.